Down On The Water

Over the years, the age of the giant flying boats has been romanticised into a gilded memory of glamorous, spacious and luxurious air transport that finally conquered the world’s greatest oceans. But if the era was really so fabulous, why was a gifted aircraft designer (and experienced air traveller) like Dr. Beverley Shenstone convinced that it had to end as quickly as possible? And why was the last-word Saunders-Roe Princess doomed before it even got wet?

‘Position Report’, September 2014

There’s a clue in the word ‘romantic’. The stark reality is revealed in the memories of Elgen M. Long, a truly remarkable pilot who first flew as a radio operator on Catalinas and Clippers. His recollections of flying boat services come to ‘airscape’ through the generosity of aviation author Mark H. Goodrich.

His article was first published in the September 2014 issue (Vol 11 No 3) of Position Report magazine, the magazine for retired airline pilots.

NC18602 ‘California Clipper’ (c/n 1989), climbs over Pan American’s Treasure Island seaplane base. Pan Am’s last serving Boeing 314, the aircraft had accumulated over a million (slow) air miles in less than a decade when retired in 1946. (Todd Lappin | CC BY-NC 2.0)

The Way It Was

By Mark H Goodrich

In my recent article on the Canadian Museum of Flight in Langley, I introduced the readership of Position Report to Elgen M. Long, holder of some 15 Fédération Aéronautique Internationale records and its Gold Medal. Captain Long started his aviation career as a radio operator and navigator on flying boats – the Boeing 314 and Consolidated PBY – and finished as a Boeing 747 Captain for Flying Tiger Airlines. Along the way, he flew many of the airline transport types between. When the navigator’s license was first initiated, he was already flying as a navigator, and took the newly required practical test on a regularly scheduled flight in a Boeing 314. When the Boeing 747 was first introduced to service some three decades later, he transitioned from the Douglas DC-8 as a captain.

I recently asked him to share with us some of ‘the way it was’ flying the Atlantic, Pacific and Caribbean in the flying boats of that earlier era. The following are the recollections of Captain Long.

Boeing 314 NC18607 (c/n 2081), which was flown by BOAC as G-AGBZ ‘Bristol’ from 1941 to 1948. (Photo supplied by Mark H Goodrich)

First Class

The dining room (yes, room) on board a Clipper. No reheated meal trays in your lap here. Mind you, meals were probably a welcome distraction on the long overwater flights. (Photo supplied by Mark H Goodrich)

“Working against the realities of slow flying at low altitudes for hours on end, the airlines went to great lengths to try and make the passenger experience first class on the Boeing 314. There were 65 seats, and about half could be converted to sleeping berths on some airplanes. Two stewards oversaw meal service and passenger comforts. At the aft end of the lower deck, there was the ‘Governor’s Lounge’, which was a VIP suite.

“The upper deck was quite large and was all for the flight crew, with work and rest stations for the pilots, flight engineer, navigator and radio operator.”

A fast airplane

The spacious and well-staffed flight deck of a typical 314A Clipper. (Photo supplied by Mark H Goodrich)

“The Boeing 314 was very unstable in the characteristically rough air at the low altitudes we flew. All flights were made at less than 4,000 feet, and some at less than 2,000 feet. We tried to stay below the clouds, so long as we could do that without risking a collision with a ship. Like most large flying boats, the hull was aerodynamically unforgiving of any slip or skid, causing the airplane to easily ‘wallow’.

“That phenomena and the turbulence at low altitudes was accompanied by very high levels of constant vibration and ambient noise. The navigator’s station was about 15 feet aft of the pilot seats, and along the port side. We had to stand in order to work at our table, and the combination of things that made the airplane unstable for hours at a time also made it difficult to stand.

“To keep our paraphernalia of the trade on the table, we used masking tape to secure the divider, drafting compass, slide rule, load calculator, charts, books, and pencils. Forgetting to tape something down would invariably result in the navigator crawling around on the floor trying to locate lost items.

The Boeing 314’s surprisingly sparse panel. With separate Radio, Flight Engineer and Navigator stations, the pilots really only needed their basic flight controls and instruments. (Photo supplied by Mark H Goodrich)

“A streamlined navigation bubble – actually a framework with several flat panes at different angles – was installed over the crew rest section for taking sun and star shots, but often higher clouds prevented the use of those techniques. Sometimes the captain would shout that he saw some sunlight shining through the overcast ahead, and aim for a spot of sunlight on the water. The navigator had to then quickly run back to the bubble and get ready to try a very fast ‘sun shot’ as the airplane passed through the shaft of sunlight. Those were the only times the 314 seemed like a fast airplane.”

Radio navigation systems

“High powered oceanic beacons were available on low-frequency for some routes, using the beat frequency oscillator for long-range tuning, but interference from conflicting ‘sky waves’ (which we now know were bouncing off the ionosphere) and ‘ground waves’ (which were ricocheting across the lower atmosphere) often created signal conflict to the point where the homing needle was unusable.

“The radio operator ‘graded’ the quality of the signal for homing based on how far it swung left and right in its oscillation pattern. After World War II, we had early versions of LORAN in the Pacific. It was quite an improvement, although not always accurate by the ‘three times T+3’ standards we later came to accept with even early inertial systems.

Another view of ‘California Clipper’ departing the Treasure Island seaplane base. (Photo supplied by Mark H Goodrich)

“After the War, we also had the Consol Radio Navigation System on some airplanes for the Atlantic routes. It used rotating beams in the medium-frequency range, and was a follow-on to the low-frequency range system developed in the USA during the 1930s, and the Sonne-Elektra system used by the Germans during the War. It was easy to use and pretty accurate out to a thousand miles and more when signals were not subject to atmospheric interference, which is to say it always worked a lot better in the daytime, and in the absence of thunderstorm activity.”

Pressure pattern navigation

“Pressure pattern navigation techniques were used when a flight would pass a low pressure center, essentially allowing the winds from one direction approaching the low and the other once past it to cancel out. Before the war, we called it the ‘constant heading technique’ for the obvious reason. Like Lindbergh, we were often a little surprised to actually ‘see Ireland’ out the window.

California Clipper NC18602 showing its orange visibility stripe. After war service as #48224 the aircraft was returned to the civil register, sold to New World Airways, and broken up in 1950. (SDASM 01-00090338)

“After the war, some airplanes were equipped with a radar altimeter to show actual altitude. We could then set the sensitive altimeter to that altitude, and derive barometric pressure so as to maintain our route along a constant pressure line. This allowed us to calculate the geostrophic wind, or the approximate geostrophic balance between the forces of Coriolis effect and pressure gradient. It was an approximation because, at our low altitudes, there were always friction effects between the prevailing winds and the surface of the earth that were not easily or accurately calculable.”

Stripped down to underwear

“Drift meters were used repeatedly throughout extended overwater legs. On the Boeing 314, the navigator had to crawl some distance out into the interior of the wing, where the drift meter was installed. We always stripped down to underwear for that exercise, as it was very wet inside the wing. That allowed us to towel off and don a dry uniform upon return to the flight deck.

“Visibility impairments and a disruptive sea surface sometimes required that we use a ‘triple-drift procedure’, turning 45 degrees off the base course and taking a drift measurement, then turning 45 degrees in the other direction from the base course to take another, and averaging the data with the base course drift data.”

NC18603 (c/n 1990 ) ‘Yankee Clipper’ seen in 1939. This aircraft crashed while turning to land at Lisbon, Portugal on February 22nd, 1943, killing 24 of the 39 on board. (Greg Bishop | CC BY-NC-SA 2.0)

Caught on a sandbar

“Flights were always scheduled so that takeoffs and landings were in daylight, which had the effect of causing extended overwater sectors to be flown in darkness. There were no instrument approaches and no underwater alignment lights for takeoff and landing, even at the large seaplane bases, such as Flushing Bay in New York City, where we used the LaGuardia Marine Terminal to enplane and deplane passengers.

“We were always subject to the primitive weather reporting and forecasting of the era, and to icing conditions, as the airplanes were without de-icing equipment.

For a sense of scale… The ill-starred NC18603 ‘Yankee Clipper’ hauled ashore on a dolly at Pan American’s Treasure Island seaplane base. (SDASM AL61A-500)

“When confronted with unforecast fog along a shoreline, the best procedure was often to land offshore, and then taxi to sheltered water along the shoreline and wait for better weather. Sometimes a pilot boat would be dispatched, but more than one captain landed in the ocean and taxied into a harbor or up a river to reach the seaplane base.

“The procedure could work well at places where boat traffic was light, like Foynes, but was too dangerous in New York or Baltimore. Gander Lake (on Newfoundland) had no ocean access, but the Pan Am crews could taxi into Botwood if they had the visibility to make a 25 mile trek through a complicated system of waterways.

“One captain got caught on a sandbar doing that. He was about to call for help when the rising tide lifted him just enough to save the day. The weather had improved while the airplane was aground. He took off again and flew the last few miles to arrive as though nothing unusual had happened.”

Mid-Atlantic misadventure

Passengers board an unidentified Pan American Clipper for a luxurious, if long, trans-oceanic flight. (Photo supplied by Mark H Goodrich)

“There were always many variables on the extended-range oceanic flights, and much that was simply beyond the control of the crew. One of our World Airways* crews landed a 314 at ‘Ocean Station Charlie’, about 780 miles east of Gander, in October of 1947. That aircraft, known as the Bermuda Sky Queen, was on a flight from Poole to New York City, with intermediate stops planned for Foynes on the river near Shannon, and Gander Lake. On board were many diplomats associated with the newly formed United Nations, including A. Edgar Ritchie, a long-time Canadian diplomat who would – some twenty years later – become Canada’s ambassador to the United States.

“Although the details of the planning for that flight have always been somewhat vague, if not outrightly controversial, official reports reflect that winds of more than 100 knots arose unexpectedly after passing the ‘point of no return’, leaving the airplane with insufficient fuel to make Gander Lake. Captain Charles Martin elected to divert to one of the eight ‘oceanic stations’ maintained across the North Atlantic at that time (each consisting of a surface ship maintaining a constant vigil within a ten square mile ‘station area’ to provide weather reports and emergency assistance).

October 14, 1947. The Bermuda Sky Queen down on the Atlantic, 780 miles east of Gander, seen from her rescue ship USCGC Bibb. (USCG Photo)

“After circling the ship at very low altitude for several hours while waiting for first light on October 14th, Captain Martin landed the airplane in seas of some 37 feet. The ship had poured oil on the water and made a series of sweeping turns to try and calm the surface somewhat, but with limited effect.

“Over a period of two days, Captain Martin and crew used extraordinary seamanship to keep the airplane upright and close to the US Coast Guard Cutter Bibb – too close from time to time, as there was a collision between airplane and ship at one point – before a successful transfer of all passengers and crew to the ship could be completed using small boats. Once all had been transferred, the Bibb crew used its 40 mm deck gun to sink the airplane.”

An exciting time in aviation

“It was an exciting time in aviation. At the start of the War, our PBY aircraft were equipped with low-frequency radios and celestial navigation gear. To spot enemy ships and airplanes, we relied on binoculars.

The venerable Consolidated PBY ‘Catalina’. With enormous range/loiter time, it was a stalwart of the Atlantic and Pacific wars. This shot is from the Aleutians, in January 1943. (Photo supplied by Mark H Goodrich)

“During the War, the state of technology increased by the week. Four years later, we had been through a technological evolution in radar, magnetic detection equipment and 12-frequency sonar buoys. Gun turrets and racks for torpedoes, bombs and depth charges had been added to the PBYs. In fact, the wings were so crowded with antennas, the Leigh Light (a high-powered searchlight used to target submarines operating on the surface in darkness) and ordnance, that we tried to avoid dropping the torpedoes, as they usually took an antenna array with them.

“The weight of the airplanes had increased so much that the Navy cut the crew complement down from ten to five by combining jobs. I started as a radio operator, and finished as a ‘radio operator – navigator – radar operator – gunner – bombardier’. The job kept getting busier as the War went on.”

Economically impractical

“The War resulted in many new runways around the world, and by five years or so after it ended, the 314s were retired even from the relatively short runs between New York and San Juan.

A Flying Tiger Line DC-4 and, behind it, a B-17 – representative of the air war that literally paved the way for more efficient land planes to replace flying boats. (Photo supplied by Mark H Goodrich)

“The airplanes were never very efficient and became very difficult to maintain. At the end, we had five airplanes from BOAC, and all were very high time. Three were usually dispatchable, and two were cannibalized as a source for otherwise hard-to-get parts.

“When the Civil Aviation Agency (CAA) starting complaining about the many fatigue cracks in the structure, the elevated maintenance and inspection schedules, not to mention the required repairs, made their continued use economically impracticable, and sealed their fate.

“The DC-4s initially took their place for most of the long-distance oceanic flying.”

With forward-facing windows

The 3,500lb Cessna Bobcat – either AT-17 or UC-78 in USAAF service. Imagine if your next twin was a 30,000lb C-46! (Photo supplied by Mark H Goodrich)

“With technology advancing so quickly, I could see the handwriting on the wall for navigators. I used my GI Bill benefits to get commercial, instrument and multi-engine licenses.

“I had a seniority number with Flying Tiger Airlines from having helped them on some of their very first flights three years earlier, and told the chief pilot that I would like to move up to seats with forward-facing windows. He gave me a flight check in the Curtiss C-46. It was substantially larger than the Cessna UC-78 I had been flying in training, but somehow I managed to keep it on the runway. My career as an airline pilot was under way.

A Flying Tiger Line C-46 Commando. Founded in 1945, Flying Tiger was the first scheduled cargo carrier in the US, and survived until 1988 when it merged with FedEx. (Photo supplied by Mark H Goodrich)

“One thing remained constant through the era of the flying boats. Many extended-overwater flights simply disappeared into the oceans of the world without a trace. Most were victims of primitive technology, unreliable forecasting and the all too unpredictable forces of nature.”

Copyright © 2014 Mark H. Goodrich.

Other aviation-related articles and white papers authored by Mark H Goodrich may be seen on his personal web-site at

6 thoughts on “Down On The Water

  1. Adventure with a capital “A”! Despite Mr. Long’s reminiscences about the hassles, slow speeds, and we-didn’t-know-what-we-didn’t-know dangers of flying in the 1930s and 40s, there was a stately elegance and swashbuckling adventurousness about those days which I wish we could capture a wee bit of in today’s flying. A hell of a time to be alive, it was!

    1. Amen to that! The trick is to preserve the adventure while keeping innocent passengers perfectly safe.
      When BOAC converted ex-Lancaster bomber pilots to airliner operations after WW2, the training Captain told them: “It is my job to convert you gallant young gentlemen into fussy old women.” Obviously they could handle a crisis, but could they avoid one…
      Still, it behooves every airplane driver to nourish their inner aviator with more some adventurous kinds of flying as often as they can.

      1. Isn’t that the truth? The risk tolerance for different types of flying varies so widely that it’s a shame they all go by the same name. Even today, the acceptable, reasonable risk level for a charter flight will be significantly different than for an aerobatic flight, even when both are conducted with passengers aboard. There’s still plenty of excitement to be had out there, plenty of old biplanes and such to put some of the romance back into aviation. It’s too bad more of the airline pilot types don’t partake of the bounty!

  2. Sounds like flying a flying boat was fun . . . and dangerous! At least it was a rugged airplane!
    I’ve always wanted to fly in a Catalina but the opportunity has never arisen. It’s a shame aviation companies don’t still make old airplanes like the Catalina, Piper Cub, and P-51 just for old times sake.

    1. I’m amazed at just how dangerous those big flying boats were – they were big, unstable and incredibly unforgiving. If you’d like to know more, follow the links to Mark Goodrich’s site and find his white paper titled ‘Amphibious Nostalgia’… On the other hand, you can still buy a Cub – and I’ve never heard a Cub pilot who didn’t say flying one is A LOT of fun… Good for your head, your feet, your hands and your soul.

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s